Democrats kick as U.S. Senate confirms Trump’s Supreme Court nominee
Democrats kick as U.S.
Senate confirms Trump’s Supreme Court nominee
Prominent Democrats have condemned the confirmation and swearing in of Judge
Amy Coney Barrett as justice of the U.S. Supreme Court. Barrett took the
constitutional oath of office before President Donald Trump at a brief ceremony
hosted by the White House on Monday night.
Coming through a 53-48 vote along party lines, Barrett’s confirmation is seen
as a victory for Trump, who nominated her following the death of liberal justice,
Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Shortly after the ceremony, Speaker of the House of
Representatives, Ms Nancy Pelosi, issued a statement accusing Trump and Senate
Republicans of committing “an act of supreme desperation”. Pelosi said they
rushed through a Supreme Court nominee just eight days before the Nov. 3
presidential election “as part of their years-long campaign to destroy
Americans’ health care”.
Democrats are worried
that the appointment of Barrett, a conservative, will favour Republicans in
politically sensitive cases pending before the apex court. One of the cases is
the Affordable Care Act enacted under the administration of former President
Barack Obama which Trump has been trying to scrap. Democrats argue that no
fewer than 20 million Americans could lose their health care coverage if the
apex court repeals the law, otherwise known as Obamacare. “In her confirmation
hearing, Justice Barrett refused to answer whether she believes that Medicare
is constitutional. “She refused to acknowledge the scientific fact that climate
change is happening, saying she isn’t a scientist, calling it ‘controversial,’”
the speaker said.
Democratic Party’s Vice Presidential
candidate, Ms Kamala Harris, described Barrett’s confirmation by the Republican
senators as despicable, saying they must be held accountable. “Instead of
working to provide COVID-19 relief to struggling Americans, Mitch McConnell and
Republicans chose to jam through a Supreme Court nominee — when more than 62
million people have already voted. “It’s despicable and they must be held
accountable,” Harris said on Twitter. Former First Lady and Secretary of State,
Mrs Hillary Clinton, also tweeted her reaction following the confirmation.
“Republicans just pushed through a Supreme Court justice who will help them
take away Americans’ health care in the middle of a pandemic,” she said.
However, Barrett said in her speech after she took the first oath of office
that her policy preferences would not influence her decisions on cases. She
said the confirmation process had made one of the fundamental differences
between the federal judiciary and the Senate clearer to her. “And perhaps the
most acute is the role of policy preferences. It is the job of a senator to
pursue her policy preferences.
“In fact, it would be a dereliction
of duty for her to put policy goals aside. By contrast, it is the job of a
judge to resist her policy preferences. “It would be a dereliction of duty for
her to give into them. Federal judges don’t stand for election. “Thus, they
have no basis for claiming that their preferences reflect those of the people.
“This separation of duty from political preference is what makes the judiciary
distinct among the three branches of government,” she said. Speaking earlier,
Trump said Barrett’s confirmation was a “momentous day for America, the United
States Constitution, and for the fair and impartial rule of law”. “The
Constitution is the ultimate defense of American liberty, the faithful
application of the law is the cornerstone of our republic. “That is why as
president I have no more solemn obligation of no greater honor than to appoint
Supreme Court justices”, Trump said. Barrett’s lifetime appointment has sealed
a 6-3 conservative majority in the nine-member Supreme Court bench. All
Democrats in the Senate voted against her confirmation, which came just a week
before the presidential election. Republican senator, Susan Collins,
representing the northeastern state of Maine, joined the Democrats in opposing
the confirmation.(NAN)
No comments